Carolina Beach's Favorite Gelato Spot

Carolina Beach Deserves
Gelato This Good

Small-batch, handcrafted gelato made fresh daily — right here on the coast. Every scoop is a little celebration of flavor.

20+ Flavors
Daily Fresh Made
Local Carolina Beach
Beautiful gelato display at Mike and Benny's in Carolina Beach
Interior of Mike and Benny's Gelato shop
Fresh gelato being scooped
Made with Love

Two Friends, One Passion,
A Whole Lot of Gelato

Mike and Benny started this little dream with nothing more than a love for real gelato and a hankering to bring something special to Carolina Beach. No shortcuts, no artificial stuff — just good ingredients, traditional methods, and a whole lot of heart poured into every batch.

Every flavor is churned fresh in small batches right here in our Carolina Beach kitchen. We source the finest chocolate, the freshest fruits, and the creamiest dairy we can find. The result? Gelato that tastes like someone actually cares about what goes into it.

Small-Batch Fresh Made daily in small batches
Real Ingredients No artificial flavors or preservatives
Right Here Proudly made in Carolina Beach

Flavors That Make You
Come Back for More

Our rotating selection features classic favorites and creative new flavors — always fresh, always delicious. Something for everyone.

Rich chocolate gelato Classic

Dark Chocolate

Rich, velvety, and deeply chocolatey — made with premium cocoa for the true chocolate lover.

Creamy pistachio gelato Fan Favorite

Pistachio

Made with real Sicilian pistachios — nutty, aromatic, and impossibly smooth.

Fresh strawberry gelato Seasonal

Strawberry

Bright, fruity, and made with real strawberries — a taste of summer in every scoop.

Classic vanilla bean gelato Classic

Vanilla Bean

Creamy, aromatic, and made with real Madagascar vanilla beans — the gold standard.

Tropical mango gelato Vegan

Mango

Luscious, tangy, and dairy-free — a tropical escape made with real mango purée.

Mixed berry gelato swirl New

Mixed Berry

A dreamy swirl of raspberries, blueberries, and blackberries — tart, sweet, and unforgettable.

Can't decide? Try a sampler — we've got you covered.

Ask About Today's Flavors

Swing By
Say Hello

Address 9 Lake Park Blvd S
Carolina Beach, NC 28428
🍦

Gelato & Ice Cream

Authentic Italian-style gelato churned fresh daily, plus creative ice cream flavors for the whole family.

🎉

Events & Catering

Planning a celebration? We offer gelato bars and catering for parties, weddings, and special events.

🌿

Vegan Options

Delicious dairy-free gelato made with coconut milk and real fruit — everyone gets a treat.

☀️

Walk-Ups Welcome

No reservation needed — just walk in and enjoy. We're right here on Lake Park Blvd, ready to serve you.

Have a Question or
Want to Order?

Whether you're curious about our flavors, planning an event, or just want to chat — we'd love to hear from you. Drop us a line and we'll get back to you ASAP.

Message Sent!

Thanks for reaching out. We'll get back to you soon!

Is this your business?This is my business